You can replace the rings but you can't replace what they represent.

I called (Tim) on his way home from work and told him I may have possibly found the rings.

I truly thought they were in the house. The only other place I thought they could have been was the doctor's office, but I figured they would be gone by now.

Short of being thrown out, we thought for sure they were in the house. I never gave it a thought that they were at the pharmacy.